Power and Consequences
Power and Consequences
Episode 38: Would You Bet Against Prediction Markets?
0:00
-38:14

Episode 38: Would You Bet Against Prediction Markets?

Power and Consequences Podcast

In the latest edition of Power and Consequences, we (Gary Gensler and Simon Johnson) discuss the latest developments—economic and legal—surrounding prediction markets.

Lots has happened for Kalshi, Polymarket, and other prediction markets in the last eight months since we released Episode Five: Prediction Markets. Volumes have grown significantly. Traditional financial firms are partnering with prediction markets, and the public followed closely the betting on the mid-term elections. Yet, multiple insider trading cases have been brought. Legislation has also been introduced to ban members of Congress and government from trading on the markets and dozens of lawsuits are raging between states and tribal authorities on the one side and the Trump administration and prediction markets on the other.

The cases boil down to the question of what Congress did in 2010’s Dodd-Frank financial reform with regard to sports betting. The Ninth and Sixth Circuit Courts of Appeal have ruled (as have many district courts) that sports-betting contracts don’t fall within the statutory definition of swaps and that Congress did not displace states’ traditional police power to regulate gaming, including sports betting. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals came out the other way.

Gary filed amicus briefs in the 2nd, 6th, & 7th Circuits providing his first hand knowledge from someone who was in the room as CFTC Chairman for the passage of Dodd-Frank Act in 2010. You can read Gary’s 2nd Circuit Amicus brief here.

The Supreme Court has been asked by New Jersey to assess the legality of sports betting on these operations. Gary filed a Supreme Court Amicus Brief in support of New Jersey. Which way will they decide?

The prediction markets themselves say that they are just trading “swaps”. They’ve also carefully assembled political connections and are working the federal regulator (the CFTC) telling the states and tribal authorities to back-off.

The states and tribal gaming authorities are not happy as most of the transactions on prediction markets are sports gambling. At risk are state-level values (control over gambling - 11 states prohibit it altogether!) plus a lot of revenue for states and tribes.

Will the administration find new ways to put its thumb on the scales of justice?

Listen to Gary & Simon’s insight on that! (Or read Gary’s amicus briefs).

Stay tuned for further fascinating developments.

Ready for more?